This product WORKS! Some people want to say it’s the product that is coming off the face, well of course the product is helping exfoliate your skin. But I can personally tell you that I have used this for months now, and it truly removes everything. This one is the gentle of the two products and this one I like to use on my cheeks, my neck. The grey one I use on my more difficult areas, like my nose and my chin. I even use this on my arms, legs, anywhere really.Trust me it works! It’s totally worth the buy! I have had smoother, and brighter skin since I started using this. I use it often and still have a lot left.